Peter Smith acts in - R v. Holker Estates Ltd, Newmac Ltd & MR. N - Trial resolves with Fines for Defendants
Peter Smith was instructed by Ciaran Garnett of Plexus Law for one of the defendants in a highly publicised case involving the tragic death of a 4 year old boy.
Holker entered a guilty plea in early 2020
to a section 3 offence; Newmac and Mr. N not guilty pleas to a section 3 offence and a section 37(1).
In March 2022, instructions were given for Newmac Ltd to enter a guilty plea to the section 3; with no trial against Mr. N; the matter of the section 37(1) being left on the file or a not guilty verdict to be recorded, adjourned to the sentencing hearing.
In the result, Holker (on a causative basis) was fined £127,500 with £27,000 costs. The court only gave Holker 25% credit notwithstanding the date of its plea.
Newmac was fined £11,000 (on a non-causative basis, with 15% credit) and ordered to pay £5,000 cost. SLDC had claimed in excess of £150,000 in costs from Newmac, who relied upon the principle that any costs had to be broadly proportionate to any fine.
The court recorded a not guilty verdict against Mr. N.
The Westmorland Gazette report can be accessed here - Companies fined after boy drowned at Old Park Wood caravan park | The Westmorland Gazette
Also Recently
-
Fraser Livesey represented the Fire & Rescue Service in a 5 day inquest where a rower drowned after going over a weir in fast-flowing water
Fraser Livesey represented the Fire & Rescue Service in a 5 day inquest where a rower drowned after going over…
Sep 11
-
DCC host The Honourable Society of Inner Temple Student event
On Friday 6th September, we were delighted to host The Honourable Society of the Inner Temple for their student event.A…
Sep 09